Editorials

Everyone Should Have an Alan Moore Moment

    It was 1984, I was 16 years old, and comics were changing, or to be exact, NOT changing.  The problem was, I was discovering girls, working a job, paying for a car, etc. etc. Although I had been a rabid comic reader since the age of 5, I was beginning to lose interest in the hobby I cherished.  I was growing up, but my comics weren't. Oh sure, there were some off-beat, small-press comics out there that dealt with mature themes, but I was turned off by the (mostly) amateur artwork and sex-drugs-life sucks- themes.   There was some previous excitement over Frank Miller's Daredevil, Claremont & Byrne's X-Men, and Wolfman & Perez's Teen Titans, but they were exceptions in a wasteland, and it seemed to me that there would never be any mainstream comic that could keep up with my growing, young-adult taste in literature.   I was becoming a more discriminating reader, and the old super-hero melodrama was losing it's appeal. Even my all-time favorite, AMAZING SPIDER-MAN, couldn't keep my interest. The Black Costume saga was in full-swing, and although it was a neat gimmick, the endless Hobgoblin sub-plot bored me to tears.   The unthinkable had happened; I was losing interest in the entire comics medium.   And for the first time in my life as a completeist,  I began dropping titles from my buying list.   In the course of only a few months, I stopped buying comics I had purchased regularly for 11 years.

     SAGA OF THE SWAMP THING #20 had a cover date of January, 1984, and it was written by a new guy named Alan Moore. The comic title itself was one I was ready to stop buying every month. The first 13 issues or so were almost painfully boring, despite the nice artwork from Tom Yeates. There seemed to be some improvement when artists Steve Bissette and John Totleben came on board with issue #16.  The book had a newer vitality, even with the same writer who had still been on board since issue one.  I decided to keep purchasing the book and give this new Alan Moore guy a try, since Bissette and Totleben were sticking around. Issue #20 came out, and it was a good read.  Overall, it wasn't an award-winner, but it ended with a cliffhanger as Swamp Thing had been attacked and almost completely destroyed by a mysterious corporation bent on finding out his secrets. Interesting enough, and I decided I'd buy the next issue.

     Oh boy. Oh boy. Oh boy. 

     Issue #21 came out (on a Monday, I think) at my local newsstand (no comic shop at that time), and I picked it up on my way back from school. Later that night, I sat down to read whatever comics I picked up that day. I propped up the pillows on my bed and stretched out.  The cover on SAGA #21 was a nice Tom Yeates effort, if unremarkable. Swamp Thing hovers menacingly in the foreground while an old guy in a suit looks panicked in the background.   No one could guess that the story inside would change the comic world.   Swamp Thing finds out that the one thing he lived for, to be human again, could never happen. His old body was destroyed, and only the consciousness of his human side remained inside the plant body.  His entire reason for being, and for the comic, was gone.

      On the surface, that doesn't sound like a story that would change the world, but it was the way Moore told the story. His pacing, suspenseful dialogue, and the overall emotional impact made it an unforgettable read. Fans immediately took notice, and Moore took a book due for cancellation to the heights of comic fandom. Within his few years on the book, it  became a best seller, won numerous American and UK awards, and Moore became the favorite writer of not only comic fans, but comic pros as well.  With Moore as an influence, it just seemed like comics got better overall. Writers were challenged to create better stories and more three-dimensional characters. Like any "trend", some writers took it too far, choosing to ape Moore's style without the originality,  but I believe his positive influence on the quality of comics can be felt to this day.  

     My point isn't just to lavish praise on Alan Moore, but to ask readers if there was a point in your life when you were ready to cast aside comics completely, or perhaps already did, but some creator or event kept you reading or brought you back. For me, it was the moment in SAGA OF THE SWAMP THING #21 when an enraged Swamp Thing kills the owner of the corporation that uncovered his secrets.  It was an Alan Moore moment that kept me interested and excited about comics.  Needless to say, I never stopped reading, and I read more than ever these days, thanks to other great writers like Peter David, Geoff Johns, Garth Ennis, and Neil Gaiman  Not all of us have such a defining moment that can be pinpointed so immediately. For some, maybe it was the return of G.I. Joe or the Transformers a few years ago, or maybe it was Neil Gaiman's SANDMAN comic. In any case, I'd love to hear from fans about a defining moment in your enjoyment of comics. What is your "Alan Moore Moment"?

    

  Feel Free to email us any responses! We'll look 'em over and post some of the best replies!

David Romeo, Jr.

Owner, Comics on the Green

 

 

 

Comics on the Green
 417 Linden Street
Scranton, PA 18503
 570-342-5960
  cotgreen@aol.com